Side by side
| Vending machine | ATM | |
|---|---|---|
| What you sell | Snacks, drinks, other products | Access to cash |
| Income per sale | Vend price minus product cost, card fee, tax and commission | Surcharge (and any interchange) minus processor fee and location share |
| Money on hand | A first fill of product | Vault cash, often more than the machine costs |
| Visits | Frequent: restock, rotate, count | Less frequent: load cash, paper, fix jams |
| Spoilage and theft | Expired product, shrink | Break-in risk; cash in transit |
| Location deal | None, percent of gross or net, or flat | None, flat monthly, or per surcharged withdrawal |
| Main rules | Sales tax, local licenses, health rules for food | State banking rules, processor and network rules |
| What grows it | More machines and better product mix | Busier locations and lower processing costs |
| Selling the route | Sales history, agreements, machine list | Processor statements, assignable agreements, location tenure |
Who each one suits
Vending suits people who do not mind the physical work of buying and stocking, like tinkering with product mix, and want to start with less cash on hand. The numbers move in small amounts per sale, so volume and margins matter.
ATMs suit people who can fund vault cash, are comfortable carrying and reconciling money, and want fewer stops. The numbers live in a few lines: surcharged withdrawals, surcharge, processor fee, location share. Check your state's banking rules first; in some states they decide whether you can operate at all.
Run one location both ways
The fastest way to decide is to take a real location and run it through both calculators: the vending placement profit calculator and the ATM profit calculator. Compare what is left each month, the cash each one ties up, and the hours on the route.
Then read the start guides: how to start a vending machine business and how to start an ATM business.